Thursday, April 15, 2010

Russia halts all adoptions to U.S.

This just in from The Los Angeles Times: 

Russia froze all adoptions to the United States on Thursday, satisfying simmering national outrage over a towheaded 7-year-old's rejection by his adoptive Tennessee mother who put him back on a plane to Moscow.

A U.S. delegation is due in Moscow in coming days to discuss the crisis with Russian officials. Russia is pressing the United States to sign an agreement that would lay out new conditions for the screening of would-be parents, and would also bind adoptive parents to a strict set of agreements on the treatment of the children.

First Mom and activist Linda Burns and pals in Austin at the capitol

If only other countries where so much corruption in the adoption system has been uncovered would do the same. Sometimes it takes a weird, desperate act to force a change in bad policy. Sometimes I dream about birth/first mothers and adopted people storming into the records vaults of state birth registries and freeing thousands and thousands of original birth certificates, so adoptees can know their true heritage and find their natural parents, and adoption records, so birth mothers can meet their children. I picture the original birth certificates available for the asking, I see blood on the steps (,aybe red paint but it will make the point) police with night sticks, screaming demonstrators by the thousands, and freedom for us enchained by the archaic, inhumane, cruel and unusual laws surrounding adoption in America.--lorraine

Protesters in Jakarta on 15 April 2010


A few links from Amazon for books about reunion:

Adoption Reunion: Ecstasy or Agony?The Adoption Reunion Survival Guide: Preparing Yourself for the Search, Reunion, and BeyondRape Adoption Reunion (Audio Cassette - Lee Ezell - Life Story) -

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is wonderful news!!!!

The U.S. Adoption Industry MUST be overhauled.

Full psych exams and background checks must be required for ALL prospective adoptive parents who want to adopt internationally or nationally.

"Home Studies" are a JOKE.

Jane Edwards said...

Good for the Russian government! A letter writing campaign to Sec'y of State Clinton asking her to support Russia in its effort to protect its children is in order.

Back to the case that caused this "crisis," I actually have a lot of sympathy for Torry Hansen.

Returning Artyom was probably the right thing but she should have done it by accompanying him to Russia. Expensive residential treatment might have ameliorated the situation but I doubt that it would have resolved his long-term problems, or hers.

The case points to the folly of adopting an older child -- or any child for that matter -- from a foreign country and believing the child will fit seamlessly into the US. Hansen seems to have been unaware that the boy's behavior stemmed from his grief in losing his natural mother (albeit she may have been a drunk who abandoned him). He took his anger out on Hansen, believing she was keeping him from his family.

If people are willing to adopt an older child, for goodness sakes, they should adopt a child in the US. Their state will provide supportive services and financial help. Additional support may come from the former foster family and the natural parents.

If people want to help children in other countries, donate to relief organizations which help families stay together.

Mandy Lifeboats said...

Feel sorry for Torry Hansen??!!
I feel about as sorry for Torry Hansen as I would for any mentally disturbed person, who refuses to take their meds. This woman and her mother, just ain't right. Bastardette has done a fantastic job of checking out details on this "weird" adoptive family. One also has to wonder about the other little adopted boy still in their charge..Logan. The only people to feel sorry for in this international incident/adoption travesty..are the children. Just sayin'.......

maryanne said...

Jane, reiterating again that the the only negative account we have of Artem's behavior comes from the Hansens who have been proven to be liars. They lied about what the lawyer told them, they lied to Artur, the driver they hired to pick Artem up at the airport, and evidently they lied to the agency.This is all documented. See Marley's blog.

There has been no professional evaluation of Artem's psychological problems published, and they sought no professional help for him during the six months they had him.

So, are we to believe them about what was wrong with Artem? I do not, because I do not trust liars, and I have no sympathy for them at all. It is immoral and should be illegal to treat a child like damaged merchandise that needs to be returned. And did you hear they had already tried to apply to adopt another child from the Republic of Georgia? They are the crazies, not that poor little kid.

e said...

Russia on the moral high ground?!

Although I doubt it will prod us into action as it should.
It is a harsh reminder of what cruelty occurs in the name of the "making families" business.

I was aghast at what that adoptive mother had done.
What that child will be like when he grows older is a frightening prospect.

Jane Edwards said...

If the Hansens are crazies as some here have suggested, it's all the more reason the little boy ought to be back in his own country with all that is familiar. The alternative would be American foster care where he would bounce around until he is 18.

maryanne said...

Oh my! Jane, you are not saying the Hansens did a good thing, are you?
I hope it will turn out as good as possible for Artem, but the whole concept of returning children alone to their country of birth is pretty horrifying.

The Hansens should never have been allowed to adopt, and they should be prosecuted for what they did to an innocent child.

I'm still not getting why there is "sympathy for the Devil" trying to cut the Hansens every possible break.

Anonymous said...

"Returning Artyom was probably the right thing."
Only if that was his clearly expressed desire.

"but she should have done it by accompanying him to Russia."
. . . and delivering him into appropriate hands that had been informed beforehand of his arrival.

"Expensive residential treatment might have ameliorated the situation, but I doubt that it would have resolved his long-term problems"
Nobody knows whether it would have helped him or not. There is no evidence she even tried.
Plus - and it's a BIG plus - the word is that she was already negotiating to adopt another child.

"or hers."
Pass the Kleenex. My cheeks are wet with tears.

"He took his anger out on Hansen, believing she was keeping him from his family."
You don't know that.
There is always the possibility that he may have been neglected or abused within that natural family and/or the orphanage, and his behavior was in response to that abuse.

"If people are willing to adopt an older child, for goodness sakes, they should adopt a child in the US."
On the whole I agree with that opinion.

Petit Perce-neige.

Anonymous said...

Preventing adoption disasters
By E.J. Graff

http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_
opinion/oped/articles/2010/04/17/preventing_
adoption_disasters/

Petit Perce-neige

Anonymous said...

"it's all the more reason the little boy ought to be back in his own country with all that is familiar."

Why would it be familiar?
Russia is an immense country. He comes from the eastern provinces of Russia and doesn't speak Russian.
He wept because he missed his "grandmother" (the woman who 'returned him to sender', apparently without even explaining what was happening to him. He was told he was going to visit "Uncle Artur", who fortunately turned out to be the very decent and concerned taxi driver who'd been paid to collect him from the airport):

http://www.moscow-driver.com/news/2010-04-09.html

The behavior of the Hansens is indefensible, and I am amazed that so many people have sympathy for them. Adoption is primarily a commitment, and the contract only the legal expression of what should be an emotionally profound human connection.

Petit Perce-neige

osolomama said...

I think anyone who suggests that returning an adopted child suddenly normalizes and restores the situation and that adoption trauma is the result of being thrown into a foreign situation should read this:

http://johnraible.wordpress.com/2010/04/18/sticking-with-a-wounded-child/

The return of a child by a parent who promised to be a parent only adds to the trauma. Unless, of course, you figure this really isn't parenthood.