' [Birth Mother] First Mother Forum: Supremes Nix "Choose Life' on License Plates

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Supremes Nix "Choose Life' on License Plates

Looks like more states will not be able to display license plates with the obviously pro-adoption slogan: Choose Life. (See Linda's post about the plates in her home state of New Jersey.)

For at least the fifth time, according to the New York Times, the Supreme Court yesterday (Oct. 5, 2009) declined to wade into the heavily litigated question of whether states can be compelled to offer specialty plates that say "Choose Life." The Court declined to hear Choose Life Illinois v. White, and thus let stand a lower court ruling that Illinois was NOT required to offer plates with the tag Choose Life, along with some 60 other styles because it had "excluded the entire subject of abortion from its specialty plate program.

But don't go dancing in the streets just yet: Twenty-two states across the country, including Maryland, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut, already have "choose-life" plates. Choose Life Inc. the Florida-based organization that started the nationwide campaign, has raised over $6 million there from at least 40,000 drivers. As Linda noted, it's the inherently pro-adoption message in the slogan and how Choose Life Inc. uses the money it gets from the plates that gives us a migraine: "The fees raised from the plates in New Jersey would go to crisis pregnancy centers, maternity homes and nonprofit adoption agencies selected by the Children First Foundation."

And who started the Choose Life campaign? And how did it get that slogan? According to NJ.com:
Elizabeth Rex, president of the Children First Foundation, said "Choose Life" isn't actually the motto of her organization. "Our slogan is 'Adoption, it's the best choice,'" she said.
After she and her husband, Charles, adopted two children, she decided she wanted to support women with unwanted pregnancies in making that decision.

We are not advocating that any group start a fund-raising campaign to get "Choose Living Death: Adoption" on a plate any time soon, but let's hear it for the Supreme Court for not giving the pro-adoption lobby yet another toehold in the public consciousness. Now we need someone in each of the 22 states that does allow the Choose Life plates to bring suit against the states--and get the bleepin' Choose Life plates off the road. --lorraine
We're not done talking about medical histories and sealed records, and will return to the subject later this week. Please continue to post comments of personal stories of how updated medical information would have been helpful to someone to yesterday's blog, below.


  1. Now, you know I would be happy to do the "choose living death: adoption" plates! I totally disagree with adoption, abortion (for myself only) and the idea that a woman has to do anything that anyone says when it comes to her own body.

    We, just like men, are the masters of our own ships.

    I hate it when someone tries to even get a word about that in on me.

    My poor sweet husband, can you imagine living with me for 27 years? LOL

  2. Yippee! Thanks for the follow-up, Lorraine. I heard a soundbyte about this on World News tonight last night but didn't follow up. Thank God the Supreme Court is following the law and not the moral majority (though I swear they're really the minority, just a lot louder and more vocal...because THEY'RE NOT HARBORING SECRETS.

  3. I was wondering why "Choose Life" wouldn't just mean giving birth and keping your child.

  4. Osolo: Not in this country, where abortion is so hotly debated. Pro-Life means only one thing: Anti-abortion, pro adoption.



COMMENTS ARE MODERATED. Our blog, our decision whether to publish.

We cannot edit or change the comment in any way. Entire comment published is in full as written. If you wish to change a comment afterward, you must rewrite the entire comment.

We DO NOT post comments that consist of nothing more than a link and the admonition to go there.